LifeSite News is a conservative news outlet that some might say is "more Catholic than the Pope." Today they introduce a series condemning the Israeli government's horrific violence
LifeSite has written extensively and courageously on Israel’s war in Gaza: Here’s why—Steve Jalsevic
Some of us originally had no idea that numerous secular and orthodox religious Jews and rabbis, and Middle East Catholic and other Christian leaders, are highly critical of Israel and its Zionist ideology.
Israeli PM Benjamin NetanyahuPhoto by Lior Mizrahi/Getty Images
Tue Oct 22, 2024 - 3:07 pm EDT
Help bring aid trucks into Gaza: LifeFunder
(LifeSiteNews) — This series of articles is a response to the often angry, intolerant, and condemning complaints and accusations received from some readers of our articles on the Israel/Palestinian conflict. This, despite us having made one of the greatest efforts in our 27-year history to ensure that everything we have written has been fully verified and supported by numerous statements, links and other evidence from a wide variety of objective, trustworthy, sometimes Christian and frequently Israeli and other Jewish information sources.
We have also found it helpful to follow some Muslim news sources that have been surprisingly objective and professional, contrary to what the Western public are propagandized to believe about them.
For the several senior-level LifeSite journalists who have been researching and writing on this issue, this has been a greater challenge than we could have initially imagined, revealing history and numerous other facts that most of us were previously unaware of.
These discoveries have been personally disturbing and heart-breaking to the point, at times, of bringing some of us to sorrow and tears seeing so many images of young Palestinian children, mothers, fathers and other innocents unjustly enduring horrific harm and suffering unlike any that we have seen in the past.
Additionally, we also came to realize that most of the Western world’s public has been woefully misinformed about the true causes, facts and now catastrophic danger the Middle East and even the world is now imminently facing from this 75-year-old conflict.
Literally millions of lives may be at stake if the more extreme Zionists now in control of Israel are not reined in by an immediate U.S. halt to its massive military “aid” for Israel’s current expansionist ambitions, as happened during past wars in the region.
I don’t recall in all 27 years of LifeSite’s existence enduring such extreme intolerance for factual news reporting that contradicts long-held, immovable views of so many readers.
I suggest that most of these critics, like ourselves, have not been aware of critical history and facts about Israel and the varied indigenous peoples of Palestine – Muslim, Christian and non-Zionist Jews. Unlike ourselves, most of the critics have been exposed to only one controlled narrative and have not had the time, inclination, or ability to research the related issues to the extent that we have.
The many alternative information sources that we discovered and unprecedented live-streamed war reporting by heroic Palestinian, Jewish, and other journalists and medical witnesses on the ground during the battles have been a Godsend. It is said that more journalists have been deliberately killed during this conflict than during any conflict since at least WWII.
subscribe to our daily headlines
US Canada Catholic
This is our daily profession, but we also realize we must strive to develop the attitude towards the critics given to us by Jesus Christ who said on the cross, “forgive them Father for they know not what they do.” It has admittedly been difficult at times, but we might have responded the same as the harsh critics if we had not asked questions, researched and learned what we did.
Primary purpose of this article series
This article series is an attempt to share with you the most important things we have learned that have most enlightened us on the conflict.
Prior to the Oct. 7 Hamas attack on Israel, most of us knew little about the tiny, but militarily and politically powerful nation of Israel. We tended to marvel how it managed to keep winning its battles against seemingly overwhelming forces from neighbouring Muslim nations and “terrorists” from within and outside its borders. It was amazing how skillful the Israelis have been at fighting wars and developing the most advanced modern weaponry and intelligence gathering systems.
We also saw Israel as a religious “nation of the Jews” fighting against frequent attacks which we assumed were the result of rabid “antisemitism,” and that all Jews were strongly supportive of Israel’s actions and celebrated its many victories over inferior enemies.
As one of the two LifeSiteNews co-founders, I have made certain that no comments or articles indicating antisemitic views are ever allowed on our website. Those who make those comments are often upset with that policy, but we disregard the complaints and consistently adhere to our principles.
However, I now realize that criticism of Zionism and the actions of its alleged “nation of the Jews”, a phrase I will explain later, has mostly not been antisemitic.
The large majority of LifeSite staff are faithful Catholics. Antisemitism is incompatible with our faith and a serious sin.
Concerns quickly developed about the “nation of the Jews.” Some of us originally had no idea that numerous secular and orthodox religious Jews and rabbis, and Middle Eastern Catholic and other Christian leaders, are highly critical of Israel and its Zionist ideology.
Most important of all, many of us were almost totally unaware of the great suffering and violence that mostly innocent indigenous Muslims, and even some Christian and orthodox religious Jews, have endured since 1948 from the more extremist Zionists who came to Palestine. They stole and occupied Palestinian Muslim homes and lands and oppressed them in the “world’s largest open-air prison” in Gaza and other similar regions in Israel.
We were exposed to frequent, high-profile reports on Islamic terrorist actions against civilians, which, of course, any humane person must condemn. Still, we had no idea that Israeli Zionists also committed numerous terrorist acts, starting with the 1948 Nakba, that killed thousands of innocent Palestinians. I don’t recall reading about those in newspapers, in school and college textbooks or watching programs or news reports about them. This, we now know, was deliberate.
This series of articles is intended to address all of the above and lay to rest false claims that LifeSite and several of its journalists are “antisemitic, “pro-Hamas,” “pro-terrorist,” not aware of the dangers of militant Islam and that we did not condemn the horrific Oct. 7, 2023 attack Israelis endured that day.
I will first set the stage of the series with comments about a number of other key, surprising facts learned about what many of us thought was a democratic, religious Jewish nation respectful of Christians and those of other faiths who have lived in Palestine for a few thousand years. l will then move on to begin the most crucial, enlightening, and extensive quoting from a wide variety of religious and non-religious Jewish critics of Israel and its Zionist ideology.
This appears to be one of the articles in the series. I have not found the rest:
Before 10/7 I had read a few books about the history of Palestine and the state of Israel. In the past year my bibliography of books has now reached five pages in length. The more I have learned, the more disgusted I have become. Absolutely nothing the US public has been told even approaches the truth about this history. Zionism is a German nationalist ideology that developed in the 19th c. in the same ferment that produced Nazism. Like Nazism, it is racist and exceptionalist. The only difference is that the "master race" is different. The early Zionists were not practicing Jews, and virtually all rabbis in the 19th c. rejected Zionism as inconsistent with observant Judaism, because the rabbis believed that the Messiah would eventually lead the Jews back to Palestine, not that they should go back there themselves and wrest it from the inhabitants. The whole story of how Zionists accomplished the feat of creating a Zionist state in Palestine is way too long and complex to rehearse here, but take it from me, it involved a whole lot of incessant lying, brutality, terrorism and just general moral depravity. The whole British Mandate period, for example, consisted of daily acts of terrorism by three Zionist terrorist gangs, who not only blew up everything in sight and shot public officials right and left as well as Palestinians and uncooperative Jews, but actually assassinated or attempted to assassinate world leaders. And once Britain abandoned the Mandate, the Zionist terrorists formed an army using the weapons they had hoarded, and then just seized the land and murdered thousands of Palestinians, driving most of the rest out of the country. The story of how they managed to get the UN to accept what they had done is another gag-inducing saga--the US and the Soviet Union are largely to blame. (Read international law scholar John Quigley's excellent history, The Legality of a Jewish State.) At no time were the Palestinians' right to self-determination remotely considered. And of course, in the 76 years since then, Israel has continued to brutally occupy, confine and murder Palestinians regularly. If the Palestinians respond with violence, then they are "terrorists." But the number of Palestinians killed by Israelis versus the reverse is thousands to one. Israel's whole economy is now based on creating weapons, surveillance technology and police training. Two further generations of Israelis have been propagandized into a kind of psychopathy.
The Catholic Church had a very uneasy relationship to the state of Israel from the beginning, because it was no secret Israel came about through terrorism. At the time the newspapers, including the Palestine and British papers, were full of what was going on (back then, reporters were not afraid to report). Furthermore, MANY thousands of Jews worldwide were NOT Zionists. A poll was taken in the US, for example, in the late 1930s, and only 4% of US Jews regarded themselves as Zionists. In 1947 and 48, the US State Department was NOT in favor of Zionists seizing Israel, but Truman overrode their objections, because it was an election year and he thought he would get more Jewish votes if he recognized the new Israeli state.
So the Catholic Church did not recognize Israel as a legitimate country until the 1980s, and only then because of extreme pressure from conservative evangelical Catholics in groups like Opus Dei, under the influence of dispensationalism, a non-scriptural Christian heresy that also developed in the 19th c. Dispensationalism has now infected all evangelical Christian sects in the US. And it certainly influenced various British politicians in the 20th c., including Balfour of the Balfour Declaration.
Nevertheless, many hundreds of thousands of Jews are still anti-Zionist. Many of the books exposing Zionism for what it is have been written by anti-Zionist Jews over the last 75 years. Many of the college students protesting the Gaza genocide are Jews. Many of the archaeologists exposing the fake narrative the Israelis use to justify their seizure of the land are Jewish archaeologists. Many of the historians exposing various false assertions Israelis make about the Palestinians are Jewish historians.
Dear Dr. Nass... I was horrified to read the article you linked to. To me, it seems plain that a large percentage of the Catholic and Christian church have been compromised by the Left and by its decades-old propaganda campaigns. Here in Maine, so many Congregational churches have LBGT banners hanging from their windows, etc. I read somewhere (I'd have to look for the article) that the American Christian church was a primary target of Marxist disinformation since the early sixties.
It's a tragedy of vast proportions---to see so many churches and pastors fall victim to propaganda.
In my article: "In Defense of Jews, Israel, and the Sacred Individual"
https://peterfalkenbergbrown.com/writings/essays/culture-and-politics/in-defense-of-jews-israel-and-the-sacred-individual/
I went through many points about the problem of conservatives buying into anti-Semitism, with questions like "How many countries has Israel invaded?" Compared to Islam and Marxism.
People forget---or never knew---that Islam conquered the countries of the Middle East by the sword. Turkey and North Africa were Christian. No more. Islam conquered Jerusalem as well. Constantinople ran with "rivers of blood" when the Muslims broke through the walls in the 1400s.
Marxism killed millions and conquered many countries as well.
How many countries has Israel conquered? Zero.
It's actions are defensive.
I think at this point, LifeSiteNews is compromised. But then again, they've featured Vigano, who is pro-Russia. Putin and Xi are buddies, looking out at the world they want to conquer.
Tucker is confused too.... Between the church, the media, the universities, and active and hostile propaganda from Islam and Marxism, good-hearted Americans are being snookered.
It's an historical tragedy. A huge tragedy.
Respectfully,
Peter Falkenberg Brown
https://peterfalkenbergbrown.com