664 Comments

Thank you Dr Meryl! I have followed all of this and heard the interview where the Breggins smeared Dr Malone terribly and I was in shock. Yes, they need to make amends! Then Dr Alexander took sides and has some other issue with the “backers” of Dr Malone years ago. It is disheartening to read fights among professionals while Rome burns and millions die. But you have stated the situation very well and thank you!

Expand full comment

The CIA and the rest of the Deep State couldn't be happier with the divisions you write about. Thank you for bringing sanity to this attempt to split up the Medical Freedom movement.

Expand full comment

From what I've seen of this, I agree wholeheartedly with Meryl's take. The targeting of Malone isn't limited to this circumstance; Berenson did it, among others. There's something really rotten about people that makes them target the clearly decent. I hope Robert and Jill know that many of us recognized this for what it was almost immediately.

Expand full comment

I have read Desmet’s book and was never under the impression that he blamed anyone for anything. I have no idea what started this spat between Malone and Bregin and I really don’t want to know know and neither do I give a rats ass what it was. But I do see people with influence taking sides and speculating about motive and getting all gossipy and judgemental and making the situation much worse.

Expand full comment

This whole thing honestly smacks to me of jealousy. If I had to guess, those who are attacking Dr Malone are envious because he is such a prominent and respected figure getting more attention and media time than they are. Who knows. But it indeed is a giant waste of time and completely counterproductive. Those who demand 100% perfection and purity of anybody better be prepared to have the same standard applied to them.

Expand full comment

Thank you Dr. Nass. Beautifully said. I have spent time with the Malone’s. I trust them and am truly grateful for the sacrifices they have made. And I am grateful for your sacrifices as well. God bless you.

Expand full comment

The lawsuit does absolutely nothing constructive.

Expand full comment

Both can be true. Psychopaths engineer conditions to cause mass formation hypnosis so as to more easily implement Totalitarianism.

I haven't followed the debate but children, its ok to disagree. Intolerance to those who think differently has really gone off the charts.

Expand full comment
Apr 1, 2023Liked by Meryl Nass

May I include a wish that Paul Alexander also bow out of this fight and apologize to Dr. Malone. His attacks have been awfully personal.

Expand full comment

Very well said and I have read books of all three. They all have valid things to say. I don't understand the necessity of criticizing the concept of "mass formation." It is unlikely that a judge will grant a victory to a public figure on such an issue. Just a lot of wasted time an energy when the real villains are still killing people with their jabs and the media is covering the scam up.

Expand full comment

I love Catherine and have learned immensely from her. I also have learned life altering things from Peter Breggin. When I first read the Breggins' attacks on Malone I thought they were extreme and unfounded. I was confused that Catherine defended him. I like your article and agree completely with your conclusions. I hope they stop attacking each other soon.

Expand full comment
founding

Very sensible and even-handed, with a comprehensive background. Thank you for coming to this with respect for both the Breggins and the Malones.

Expand full comment

Hear, hear. A reflection my thoughts well said, thanks. I always felt mass hysteria. But others can call what happened however they wish. Watching learned people attack each other over slights is sad, beneath them both.

"But before I knew the regulators were bought criminals, I vaccinated an awful lot of people." - I was duped into the first two shots, as many other elders, because I trusted. Once data arrived, I saw hazards and refused boosters. My trust is gone.

Expand full comment

Hi, for what its worth, having stood behind a prescription counter for 21 years, it is common feeling among the pharmacy community that psychiatrists seem to be both the most psychologically troubled individuals prescribing drugs and as a group sadly know little or nothing about the medications they themselves prescribe. This may seem off topic but an article on the latest school shooting in Tennessee off handedly mentions that this trans individual was going thru depression and was "under a doctor's care". OOh OHhh The alarm bells went off and my guess would be she/he was taking a witches brew of SSRI meds and benzos like Klonopin, a combination regularly "prescribed" by psychiatrists but almost always designed to cause severe adverse effects and dependency in the patient. The patients swing between anxiety and depression and BOTH meds have the potential of aggressive flare ups to suicide/homicide! Add them together and wow... you get everything from Columbine to the German plane crash in the Alps. We have known about the dangers of such meds for decades but instead of addressing them, the doctors brush them off and write more scripts for them.

So I don't know either Breggin or Malone but have seen them on videos and think they are both very smart, but feel the attack on Malone is more than a bit unhinged and makes me wonder if Dr Breggin all that stable.... either way it serves no positive purpose to the World at large but I can't blame Dr. Malone for taking it personally. As I once said "Nothing Personal" should have been the "motto" over the gates at Auschwitz..

Expand full comment
Apr 1, 2023Liked by Meryl Nass

Meryl, Malone started the Unity Project whose whole goal was to protect kids against these shots. I’ve never heard him say anything at any time that undermines the medical freedom views of you or CHD. He is, I believe an integral man and these attacks against him are sickening and childish. Gayln Perry,MD

Expand full comment
Apr 1, 2023·edited Apr 1, 2023

Meryl, I highly recommend reading this substack by Dr. Paul Alexander about his own experiences with Dr. Malone, Dr. Cole, Dr. McCullough, the Breggins, and others in the truth movement. No one else is dividing the movement more than Malone has. The lawsuit should be a huge red flag for everyone.

https://open.substack.com/pub/palexander/p/ryan-cole-you-took-a-shot-at-me-in

Expand full comment