Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Everything Voluntary Jack's avatar

Thanks, Meryl, an important, unearthed article.

I appreciate your tireless work.

“In a place where there are no humans, one must strive to be human.” Hillel, the Elder

Sasha Latypova's avatar

Meryl, with due respect, this is a white paper, a review of reports by others, from a self-interested "center for non-proliferation", hardly an unbiased group! These are some of the people who clamor for biodefense dollars. I have not read the whole thing, only first few pages, but they contain a number of bad examples of fear mongering for money. Even if the summarized instances of the "lab escapes" are true, they hardly amount to pandemics. Smallpox examples: the largest was 80 cases - that's a pandemic? The H1N1 flu - in one of the examples, miraculously, pandemic is "restricted to under 21 year olds" - huh? what a marvelous very intelligent virus. Spanish flu has been utterly discredited by many authors. and other "avian" influenzas likewise. This paper is not evidence of anything other than the authors are asking for government dollars for "biodefense" and "nonproliferation". While I totally agree that no funding should be given for bioengineering of viruses (whatever that is), I also think the groups like the authors of this paper should have no funding either. Then this dangerous nonsense will stop.

80 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?